Many Tornado Alley Residents With Disabilities Lack Safe Options In A Storm

Feb 18, 2020
Originally published on February 18, 2020 1:43 pm

John High has diabetes, which led to his leg being amputated below the knee two years ago. He's been using a wheelchair since then, and hasn't gotten used to having to work out solutions to everyday problems — such as getting in and out of the shower in the small rental house he shares with his son in Norman, Okla. But when he hears a tornado siren blaring out its high-pitched warning he feels a spasm of fear and dread. In this situation, he's on his own.

"I just pray. That's all I can do," High says. "They expect people to 'shelter in place,' but I don't have anywhere safe to go."

Other Oklahomans have had to adapt too. Few homes have basements, so those who can afford do so build or purchase their own shelters. But High can't afford the kind he would need — one that would allow him to quickly roll his motorized chair right inside. And no one but him seems to see this as a problem.

The most common tornado shelters have steep stairs, making them inaccessible to people with ambulatory disabilities. The base model, found in some backyards in Oklahoma, is an underground concrete box, like this one.
Jackie Fortier / StateImpact Oklahoma

"One person told me 'put on a football helmet and go into your kitchen,' " High recalls with a bitter smile. He gestures toward the walls: "I've got a window in every room of this house, so there's really no place for me to go."

He wasn't always in this situation. High chose this rental house in 2008 because of its proximity to a public school that was an officially-designated public shelter. From his driveway, High can see the elementary school just down the street. It would take just four minutes for him to roll down a ramp, travel along the sidewalk, and get inside the school gym.

But access to most places that have served as public shelters in the past, including that gym, ended a few years ago, after fire officials and others argued that the public shelters weren't up to federal standards. Effectively, that change in policy left Oklahomans like High to fend for themselves.

The protective gold standard, for people who live in tornado-prone regions, is a storm shelter also known as a safe room. You can buy them at big box hardware stores, or have concrete shelters built by specialty companies, but they range in price from a few thousand to tens of thousands of dollars, depending on the size and materials. The base model is just a concrete room set into the ground, usually in a backyard. But to get inside, people must climb down a ladder or steep set of stairs. There are above-ground models that are wheelchair accessible, but those cost more.

High relies on federal disability payments for his income, and says he simply can't afford to pay for his own shelter.

"What bill am I going to not pay, to try to save up $3,800? I live day to day. Every month is really rough," he says.

Local towns started closing public shelters in Oklahoma a few years ago, to avoid the costs of making them tornado-safe. There was no mandate that they keep them open. High now thinks the federal or state government needs to step in and help people with disabilities acquire their own storm shelters.

"We're [in] tornado alley. We're known for it. Why aren't they helping to protect us?" he says. "Instead it's 'Well, just duck your head and go in your house.'"

Climate change is making storms worse

Data collected and analyzed by the Center for Public Integrity found that between 2009 and 2018, Oklahoma had the highest number of major disaster declarations in the country: They ranged from severe storms, floods and fires, to ice storms and tornadoes. According to the 2018 National Climate Assessment, many of these weather-related hazards are expected to become worse and more frequent because of climate change.

"If you're able to install a safe room in your home, or on your property, we recommend that you do that," says Keli Cain, a spokeswoman for the Oklahoma Department of Emergency Management. "It's the safest place that you can be during a storm."

Despite experiencing some of the most severe weather-related events in the nation, Oklahoma has no state laws requiring storm shelters in homes, apartments or businesses. Instead, storm shelters are marketed as a desirable, extra amenity in some new housing developments.

If a community wants to open a local storm shelter for the public, that's up to local officials, Cain explains. "Community shelters are funded on their own, either through bond issues or other funding methods," she says.

There also is no database that Oklahomans can consult, showing where public or wheelchair-accessible shelters are located. "We don't have a listing of the community shelters," Cain says. "They don't have to register it through the state or anything, unless it's funded by a [federal] grant program."

Oklahoma does offer a storm shelter rebate program, funded by the Federal Emergency Management Agency. Cain says the annual grant is enough to help about 50 households a year to install storm shelters, with applicants getting up to $2,000 to help cover the cost. But the grants are allocated randomly through a lottery system that doesn't take socioeconomic status into account — and it's restricted to homeowners. Renters, like John High, can't even apply for the grants.

Cain blamed FEMA rules for that exclusion, acknowledging its particular impact on people with disabilities.

"There is no specific program to help people with disabilities get a storm shelter," Cain says. "Some people might have to leave their homes a couple hours before the storm, and go to a place that is safe."

Many FEMA programs do restrict disaster-aid funding to homeowners, and that has spurred litigation.

Americans with Disabilities Act turns 30

In July 1990, President George H.W. Bush signed the Americans with Disabilities Act into law. The ADA attempted to break down the barriers by requiring businesses, schools and other organizations to take basic steps to accommodate a range of health challenges, including impairments of sight, sound and mobility.

"Fifteen percent of the population is over the age of 65," says Marcie Roth, CEO of the World Institute on Disability. "Within the next 40 years, this will grow to 1 in 4 people in the United States. In an emergency, you can count on the fact that people with disabilities will be affected."

The ADA has been modified over the years to include emergency preparedness, but the problem remains, bursting into public consciousness after major weather events like Superstorm Sandy, which hit New York and New Jersey in 2012, and Hurricane Harvey, which devastated the Texas and Louisiana Gulf Coast in 2017. In the aftermath of those storms, Roth says, people with disabilities were left without access to vital medicines and care; she blames poor disaster planning on both the state and local levels.

As a consequence of those storms, and the resulting backlash from many in the disability community over the lack of planning, the federal government sent the states guidance on how to comply with the ADA in emergency situations. But the implementation of those directives has been haphazard, Roth says, as evidenced by the devastation caused by Hurricane Maria, a deadly Category 4 hurricane that ravaged Puerto Rico, the Virgin Islands and Dominica in 2017.

"Interruption of medical care and disability services was the primary cause of almost 3,000 deaths following Hurricane Maria," Roth says. "Emergency planning needs to be inclusive of the whole community and it needs to be equally accessible to everyone in the community."

Sara Pratt is a former official at the Department of Housing and Urban Development specializing in housing and disability rights, and helped write the guidance sent to states. Now a civil rights lawyer in Washington, D.C., Pratt thinks that Oklahoma may be violating the ADA.

"The idea that we don't have to serve people with disabilities who are renters is not consistent with federal law," says Pratt.

Federal civil rights laws, including the Fair Housing Act and the ADA, require accommodations for people with disabilities in all disaster programs, Pratt says, including mitigation.

"The programs that are being offered to assist people who are sheltering in their homes should be available to both homeowners and renters if they have disabilities and have disability-related needs," she says. "There has to be an opportunity for a person with a disability to shelter."

More than 630,000 people in Oklahoma have a disability, but the state doesn't know how many of them need storm shelters. Some local governments keep track of how many households already have one, but there is no shelter reporting-requirement.

Request for financial assistance

John High says he'd like to see the public shelters reopened.

"Some people don't even know the shelters are gone yet," he says. "If you don't need something, you don't think about it until it's necessary."

If the shelters don't reopen, High says he'll keep trying to get financial assistance to get an accessible storm shelter in his home. He plans to put it in the garage, so he can easily drive his wheelchair in, but so far he's encountered a web of regulations.

"Every time I hear the tornado siren, I fear — I fear for my life," he says. "If a tornado comes through here, I'm going to be dead."

This story was first reported as part of The Center for Public Integrity's series on insufficient protections for vulnerable people against natural disasters. It is part of NPR's reporting partnership with StateImpact Oklahoma and Kaiser Health News. You can follow Jackie Fortier on Twitter: @JackieFortier.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

If a tornado was coming, where would you go? The question is particularly fraught for people with disabilities who live in Tornado Alley. Take Oklahoma, where 146 tornadoes touched down just last year. The state's public shelters were often wheelchair-accessible. But as Jackie Fortier reports, those shelters have been closing their doors.

JACKIE FORTIER, BYLINE: John High (ph) knows that when he hears a tornado siren wailing across the city of Norman...

(SOUNDBITE OF TORNADO SIREN)

FORTIER: ...He's on his own.

JOHN HIGH: Just pray - that's all I can do.

FORTIER: That's because in the house he rents, he doesn't have a safe place to go.

HIGH: One person told me, put on a football helmet and go in your kitchen. I got a window in every room in this house. Even my bathroom has a window. So there's really no place for me to go, and that's why I'm trying to get a shelter.

FORTIER: It used to take him just a couple of minutes to drive his motorized wheelchair to the nearest public shelter, a school just down the block. It was the main reason he chose to rent this house when he moved back to Norman. But most public shelters were shut down a few years ago to cut costs, leaving Oklahomans like High to fend for themselves.

HIGH: I fear. I fear for my life, you know? When - at least when the shelters were there, we could go down four houses away to a shelter.

FORTIER: The gold standard for people who live in tornado-prone areas is a storm shelter. The base model is just a concrete box set into the ground, usually in a backyard. To get in, you have to go down a steep set of stairs or a ladder. High needs a more expensive above-ground shelter that he can drive his wheelchair into in the few minutes before a tornado hits. He can't afford to pay for it on his own.

HIGH: What bill am I going to not pay to try to save up $3,800? I mean, I live day to day. I mean, every month is really rough. We're Tornado Alley. We're known for it. Why aren't they trying to help protect the - instead of, well, just duck your head and go in your house.

FORTIER: Oklahoma experiences some of the most severe weather events in the nation but has no state laws requiring storm shelters in homes, apartments or businesses or nearby.

KELI CAIN: We recommend that if you're able to install a safe room in your home or on your property, we recommend that you do that. That's the safest place that you can be during a storm.

FORTIER: Keli Cain is a spokesperson for the Oklahoma Department of Emergency Management. The state does have a rebate program that gives about 50 people a year $2,000 towards the cost of a storm shelter. It's funded by a grant from the Federal Emergency Management Agency. But it's a random lottery system, and renters like John High can't even apply.

CAIN: It's for homeowners only, and that's part of the federal grant requirement.

FORTIER: That's unfair to renters, according to advocates, and people with disabilities tend to rent more.

Sara Pratt is a former official at the Department of Housing and Urban Development.

SARA PRATT: There has to be an opportunity for a person with a disability to shelter.

FORTIER: One way to help would be to allow renters to be eligible for the shelter rebates or prioritize the most vulnerable, like people with disabilities or even the elderly - anyone in Oklahoma who can't get themselves underground fast. Pratt wonders why Oklahoma even bars renters from getting a shelter rebate.

PRATT: The idea that we don't have to serve people with disabilities who are renters is not consistent with federal law.

FORTIER: Laws like the Fair Housing Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act, for example, say people with disabilities must have the same opportunities as everyone to participate in federal programs, such as disaster preparation. After the city of Norman closed the public shelter near his house, John High tried other ways to stay safe. He asked the city to reconsider. He asked them to buy him a shelter. The answer was always no.

HIGH: If a tornado comes through, I'm going to be dead.

FORTIER: Federal data shows that between 2009 and 2017, Oklahoma had the highest number of major disaster declarations of any state. That includes severe storms, fires, floods, ice storms and, of course, tornadoes. Many of those hazards are expected to become worse and more frequent due to climate change.

For NPR News, I'm Jackie Fortier in Norman, Okla.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.