Amanda Williammee pauses at the window of the toddler classroom at Horizons day care in Carrboro, N.C., to quietly check on her 2-year-old daughter Taycee.
"I like to peek in on her and see what she's doing before she sees me," Williammee says. "I love watching her — it's too funny."
There's a dance party in progress. Soon, Taycee spots her mom, screams and comes running to the door.
"Did you dance?" Williammee asks, leaning down to her daughter.
It seems to be a pretty typical preschool pickup, but it's not. Tied to the University of North Carolina Medical Center, Horizons is a residential substance use disorder treatment program where mothers undergoing treatment can bring their children. The kids attend school or day care while mothers take classes and go to therapy sessions.
Williammee, now 25, has struggled with addiction since she was a 19-year-old college student. She injected opioids during both her pregnancies and both of her babies were born with neonatal abstinence syndrome — a condition that includes drug withdrawal symptoms like tremors, irritability, sleep problems and high-pitched crying. Williammee remembers that withdrawals were harder for Taycee than they've been for 6-month-old Jayde.
"It wasn't just like we had this two-week period at the hospital of her being sick. It went on for months because she did not sleep," Williammee remembers. In those days Taycee only slept for 20-minute stretches and needed constant swaddling.
On average, a baby is born in withdrawal from opioids every 15 minutes in the U.S., according to recent research. That staggering statistic raises concerns among doctors and social workers — and among mothers like Williammee.
Today, both Taycee and Jayde are developing normally. Still, Williammee wonders about the risk of lasting effects on each child's body and brain.
Research is just beginning to point toward the answers. Recently, an international, multisite study tracked for 36 months nearly a hundred children whose mothers had been in medically-assisted treatment during their pregnancy. Hendrée Jones is executive director at Horizons and co-authored the study. She says the early results suggest there are reasons to be optimistic.
"The children through time tended to score within the normal range of the tests that we had," Jones says.
Dr. Stephanie Merhar, a neonatologist at Cincinnati Children's Hospital, released a separate study after growing increasingly worried the past few years as she treated children coming in for checkups. Her team reviewed the charts of 87 2-year-olds who had been diagnosed with neonatal abstinence syndrome at birth. Each child had been given a standard test for 2-year-olds that evaluated cognitive, language and motor skills — the same assessment used in Jones' study.
Merhar says what her team found was a call to action.
"Most of these children do well, and they do within the normal range," she says. There is still a risk these kids may experience some delays as they continue to grow, she adds, so they should be monitored closely.
The problems Merhar found among children exposed to opioids in utero include about 8 percent who need treatment for strabismus, or lazy eye, by age 3. A number of the children also scored at least one standard deviation below the mean in terms of cognitive, language and motor skills.
The underlying reason for those delays is unclear, she says, and the long-term outlook for the children is still unknown.
Still, exposure to opioids in utero does not appear to be as damaging as some other addictive substances.
"It's not like the fetal alcohol syndrome problem, where it really affects the brain," Merhar says. "[Children with fetal alcohol syndrome] are at high risk of mental retardation and there are significant developmental delays."
Dr. Jonathan Davis, who chaired a Neonatal Advisory Committee for the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, is calling for more longitudinal research.
Davis, who is also chief of newborn medicine at Floating Hospital for Children at Tufts Medical Center, has passionately advocated for a national registry for babies exposed to drugs while in the womb.
While findings so far haven't found major delays, he says, there's a chance subtler effects might yet emerge. "How are these children going to function when they get to school?," he wonders. "How are these children going to speak, socialize and interact?"
Dr. Lauren Jansson, director of pediatrics center for addiction and pregnancy at Johns Hopkins Medicine, has treated mothers and babies since the early 1990s. When asked about how these opioid-affected babies are likely to develop, she says "the one solid thing we can say about children who are exposed to substances prenatally is that their mothers need treatment."
Horizons opened its program in 1993 because of the cocaine epidemic. Since then, Jones says, it has become clear that the lives of people with substance use disorders — whether it be cocaine or opioids — can be very chaotic, and that chaos might be as damaging to their children as the direct effects of the drugs.
Treat the parents, and kids benefit, too.
Most of the mothers at Horizons took multiple substances when pregnant and also experienced trauma, abuse or neglect in their own childhoods. And that can be hard to overcome, Jones says
"There's often times an unrealistic expectation by society, she says. "They're supposed to automatically know how 'be good mothers' — how to be nurturing mothers. That's like trying to teach somebody algebra when they've never even had addition."
Horizons' residential treatment program now pairs parenting classes with addiction treatment.
In an interview inside her homey, staff-monitored apartment, Willammee describes why this time will be different.
"It's going to work," she says. "It is. I've got a lot of tools to take with me and use in my life to stay clean, instead of using drugs to cover up my feelings and take their place, when something's hard."
Another motivator: The local child protective services agency has threatened to take Taycee and Jayde away this time, if Williamee doesn't stay clean. The little girls are napping in the next room as Willammee talks.
"I'm not just some drug addict," she says. "I'm a mother of two kids. And I feel like I'm a great mother. I have educational goals I plan to accomplish, and I plan on being a productive human being in our society."
Williammee is now working hard to finish up 18 months of college classes so she can graduate. She wants to become a teacher.
MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:
All right, to other news now. Researchers estimate that every 15 minutes here in the U.S. a baby is born who is withdrawing from opioids. That statistic, that staggering statistic, raises concerns about how the drugs affect the long-term health of children. There is little research to go on. Sarah Jane Tribble brings us this report.
SARAH JANE TRIBBLE, BYLINE: It seems to be a pretty typical preschool pickup, but it's not.
AMANDA WILLIAMMEE: I like to peek in on her and see what she's doing before she sees me.
TRIBBLE: Amanda Williammee sees her 2-year-old daughter Taycee before opening the classroom door. There's a dance party in progress. Then Taycee spots her mom.
TAYCEE WILLIAMMEE: Hey. Hey.
WILLIAMMEE: OK. OK. Did you dance?
TRIBBLE: We are at Horizons in Carrboro, N.C. It's a place where mothers can bring their children and get the residential treatment they need for substance use disorder. Now it's time to pick up Williammee's 6-month-old girl Jayde.
WILLIAMMEE: What has she got?
TRIBBLE: Williammee injected opioids during both of her pregnancies, and her babies were born with neonatal abstinence syndrome. She remembers that withdrawals were harder for toddler Taycee than they've been for Jayde.
WILLIAMMEE: And it wasn't just like we had this two-week period at the hospital of her being sick. Like, it went on for months. She'd sleep for 20 minutes, and then she'd wake up and just be miserable.
TRIBBLE: Today both Taycee and Jayde are developing normally. Still, Williammee worries. How did the drugs affect their tiny bodies and brains? Research is just beginning to point towards the answers. A recent study has found reasons to be positive. Hendree Jones is executive director at Horizons and co-author of that study.
HENDREE JONES: The children through time tended to score within the normal range of the tests that we had.
TRIBBLE: Neonatologist Dr. Stephanie Merhar at Cincinnati Children's Hospital released a separate study. Overall, the children in both short-term studies developed within normal ranges for cognitive, motor and speech development. Merhar's data, though, did show that some children experienced notable delays and hinted that there could be problems down the road.
STEPHANIE MERHAR: It's important to know that there is a risk for some delays and that these kids are monitored closely.
TRIBBLE: But the reason for those delays is unclear, whether it's related to drugs or environment or both. Researchers are quick to point out that fear spread nationwide about the children of the crack cocaine epidemic of the 1980s and early '90s. Dire predictions of developmental delays turned out to be grossly exaggerated, according to the National Institutes of Health. The Horizons treatment center actually had its start back then. Jones says the lives of people who use substances are often chaotic, and that affects their children in a variety of ways.
JONES: It's incredibly difficult to make a simple linear cause and effect between there was a prenatal exposure to opiates; therefore, we see this particular poor birth outcome.
TRIBBLE: Most of the mothers at Horizons took multiple substances when pregnant and also experienced trauma, abuse or neglect in their own childhoods. And Jones says that can be hard to overcome.
JONES: They haven't had positive role models. You know, I think there's oftentimes an unrealistic expectation by society. They're supposed to automatically know how to be, quote, unquote, "good mothers," how to be nurturing mothers. And that's like trying to teach somebody algebra when they've never even had addition.
TRIBBLE: That's why Horizons pairs parenting classes with addiction treatment. Williammee began in February. On a recent afternoon, Jayde and Taycee are napping. Her apartment has the feel of home. There's a Pack 'n Play near the dining room table, baby bottles drying on the kitchen counter. She takes a deep breath before answering a question about why this is her third try at Horizons.
WILLIAMMEE: It's going to work. It is because I've got a lot of tools to take with me and to stay clean instead of using drugs.
TRIBBLE: And Child Protective Services has threatened to take Taycee and Jayde.
WILLIAMMEE: I'm not just some drug addict. I'm a mother of two kids. And I feel like I'm a great mother. I have educational goals I plan to accomplish. I plan on being a productive human being in our society.
TRIBBLE: A paper following babies up to 2 years old is expected out later this year. But national experts say there is no long-term research underway that watches children as they go through grade school and beyond. For NPR News, I'm Sarah Jane Tribble.
(SOUNDBITE OF BENJAMIN CLEMENTINE'S "FAREWELL SONATA") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.